Skip to content
Real Estate Deal Analysis & Advice

User Stats

2,207
Posts
6,589
Votes
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
6,589
Votes |
2,207
Posts

Cat Litter House: Flip # 653 and it could be the worst one yet. Look at the pics and you decide.

Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
Posted Jun 15 2014, 15:21

Some flips are easy...paint, carpet, clean, and list.  Then there are the hard ones. 

I've never posted a diary of a flip before.  With over 600 flips under my belt I sometimes think that I've seen it all.  Then I see something I haven't seen before.  This time, It's so outrageous that I couldn't resist sharing.  I'll share the visuals, but fortunately for you I can't share the smells.  This is kind of a diary and kind of not...I bought it in January so you don't get the day-by-day play-by-play, but it's not done yet so this isn't old news either.

I came across this deal from a wholesaler who I met on BP (thanks yet again BP for making me money).  He hadn't seen the house in person but he had heard it was in bad shape.

I sent my acquisitions guy down there to look at the house. When he came back he said, "that's the worst house I've ever seen." At first I thought "Come on, really? You've looked at over a thousand houses for me!" Ultimately, I took his word for it. We threw a number at the rehab and ARV and made an offer. It was accepted.

Here are the numbers:

ARV $400,000 (probably a little more, I hope)

Rehab $175,000 (probably a little less, I hope)

Since there were some unknowns I had to make a conservative offer.  It would take a while to fix this place up, so I had to add some margin to cover the carrying costs. 

My offer: $125,000.

Closing was about a month later.  The seller agreed to move out and leave the key at the title company.  On move-out day, I went down to the house to see it for myself for the first time.  When I opened the front door, this is what I saw.

Ok, so now I knew that my acquisitions guy was right!  We were in for it!

Have you ever seen anything like it?  Wait, it gets worse.  More to follow!

User Stats

2,207
Posts
6,589
Votes
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
6,589
Votes |
2,207
Posts
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
Replied Jun 29 2014, 20:42

@Account Closed I have one offer already, it came in a couple of hours ago.  :)

Account Closed
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Marysville, OH
195
Votes |
242
Posts
Account Closed
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Marysville, OH
Replied Jun 29 2014, 21:09

This is one of the best threads I have ever read.  I had to show my wife just now and she could not believe the pictures.

What sort of disclosure did you make to potential buyers if any about the state of the house previously?

BiggerPockets logo
BiggerPockets
|
Sponsored
Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes

User Stats

410
Posts
337
Votes
Douglas Larson
Pro Member
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Salt Lake City, UT
337
Votes |
410
Posts
Douglas Larson
Pro Member
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Salt Lake City, UT
Replied Jun 29 2014, 21:55

Wow!... best flip ever!

User Stats

308
Posts
94
Votes
Chris Vail
  • Investor
  • Sacramento, CA
94
Votes |
308
Posts
Chris Vail
  • Investor
  • Sacramento, CA
Replied Jun 29 2014, 22:07

@Brian Burke 

Thank you for sharing your journey, this thread has been fantastic.  You will deserve the profit that you pull down with this deal.  Talk about seeing the forest through the trees, awesome job.

User Stats

2,207
Posts
6,589
Votes
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
6,589
Votes |
2,207
Posts
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
Replied Jun 29 2014, 22:21

@Account Closed No disclosure yet...I just got my first offer today.  In conjunction with the response to any offer, I'll include a photo collage of the before pictures.  My transfer disclosure statement will also include language about the former condition, what was done, etc.

Sellers are required to disclose all known defects.  In a typical flip, most or all known defects are corrected during rehab, so I normally don't go into much detail on a property's "before rehab" condition, but this one is a special case.  I'd rather have a buyer walk away now than find out from neighbors after COE...

User Stats

64
Posts
31
Votes
Rich Cee
  • Investor
  • Cape Coral, FL
31
Votes |
64
Posts
Rich Cee
  • Investor
  • Cape Coral, FL
Replied Jun 29 2014, 23:37

Burke, you deserve the profit brother. Lemon's into Lemonade? Try poop into a Corona!!! Great job!

User Stats

467
Posts
107
Votes
Charmaine M.
  • Queens NY, NY
107
Votes |
467
Posts
Charmaine M.
  • Queens NY, NY
Replied Jun 30 2014, 08:03

Brian, i just want to thank you for keeping me motivated, inspired and determined.

My market is very difficult to get into when you are newbie, but this post keeps me moving along when i get discourage.

Great work and many more success!!!

Account Closed
  • Investor
  • Central Valley, CA
3,724
Votes |
6,037
Posts
Account Closed
  • Investor
  • Central Valley, CA
Replied Jun 30 2014, 09:23

@Brian:  when you have time, I have rehab questions. I'm always on the look out for when economy and goof taste come together, so I'm looking at it with a totally different eye than your buyer.

 Is the flooring product on the main floor engineered wood flooring, or laminate?  The listing says laminate, but it looks better than laminate in the pictures.

Where's the utility/laundry area in this house?  I'm familiar with the house layout as there's a subdivision in one of my farms with same houses built 1976 - 1982. The laundry closet has been near or under the stairs.  Is there a utility area, or are the hookups in the garage?

Is the 4th bedroom an office off the family room area?

What was the thinking behind the double door entry to the master bedroom?  Was it that way already?

Is the back patio poured, or is that just block set on top of sand or dg to suggest patio?

User Stats

85
Posts
8
Votes
Gil Lieblich
  • Real Estate Investor
  • North Brunswick, NJ
8
Votes |
85
Posts
Gil Lieblich
  • Real Estate Investor
  • North Brunswick, NJ
Replied Jun 30 2014, 09:36

Really amazing job... love the transformation. Looking forward to seeing all the numbers and break down so i can have a better understanding of what to expect if i ever get to tackle a situation like this.

User Stats

2,195
Posts
1,022
Votes
Aly W.
  • Investor
  • Middletown, NJ
1,022
Votes |
2,195
Posts
Aly W.
  • Investor
  • Middletown, NJ
Replied Jun 30 2014, 09:57

Excellent work, what a project! All the best!

User Stats

2,377
Posts
1,107
Votes
Bob E.
  • Queen Creek, AZ
1,107
Votes |
2,377
Posts
Bob E.
  • Queen Creek, AZ
Replied Jun 30 2014, 11:21

And to think I was in a licensing class a few months ago where they mentioned that hoarders are now protected under ADA.

User Stats

105
Posts
28
Votes
Joe Demonte
  • Costa Mesa, CA
28
Votes |
105
Posts
Joe Demonte
  • Costa Mesa, CA
Replied Jun 30 2014, 12:29

Fantastic job, @Brian Burke . You deserve a round of applause with taking this project on. I wish you the best from it, and thank you for sharing with the BP community!


Its a great record kept for a seasoned real estate investor like yourself. 

User Stats

105
Posts
28
Votes
Joe Demonte
  • Costa Mesa, CA
28
Votes |
105
Posts
Joe Demonte
  • Costa Mesa, CA
Replied Jun 30 2014, 12:30

Double post... Cant delete 
:(

User Stats

2,207
Posts
6,589
Votes
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
6,589
Votes |
2,207
Posts
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
Replied Jun 30 2014, 13:31
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

@Brian:  when you have time, I have rehab questions. I'm always on the look out for when economy and goof taste come together, so I'm looking at it with a totally different eye than your buyer.

 Is the flooring product on the main floor engineered wood flooring, or laminate?  The listing says laminate, but it looks better than laminate in the pictures.

Where's the utility/laundry area in this house?  I'm familiar with the house layout as there's a subdivision in one of my farms with same houses built 1976 - 1982. The laundry closet has been near or under the stairs.  Is there a utility area, or are the hookups in the garage?

Is the 4th bedroom an office off the family room area?

What was the thinking behind the double door entry to the master bedroom?  Was it that way already?

Is the back patio poured, or is that just block set on top of sand or dg to suggest patio?

The flooring is laminate, but I agree that it looks like engineered hardwood.  It's just really good laminate, and it's really inexpensive.  Well, we just negotiated a really good deal on it, I guess volume counts for something.

Laundry room is between the family room and the garage.  It's adjacent to the downstairs half bath, which is adjacent to the staircase.

The fourth bedroom is really a den or office.  Originally it was part of the master bedroom as a sitting room.  This floor plan was originally built as a flex plan with a builder option of master with a sitting room or 4th bedroom.  Looking at the market, I noticed that there were very few 4-bedrooms on the market so it seemed the way to go.  Putting up one wall gives the 4th bedroom, but it's too small to put in a closet.  So it's a den.  But it's now downstairs by the family room, it's upstairs.

The double-door entry to the master was an existing design.  While the doors are new, the opening isn't.

The back patio is pavers on sand.  This allows flexibility if the new owners wanted to tear it out and do a deck or something different.

User Stats

20
Posts
7
Votes
Sheena Breedlove
  • Brooklyn, NY
7
Votes |
20
Posts
Sheena Breedlove
  • Brooklyn, NY
Replied Jun 30 2014, 14:33

I can't wait to see what you do with this place!!

User Stats

195
Posts
138
Votes
Robert G.
  • Residential Real Estate Agent
  • Miami, FL
138
Votes |
195
Posts
Robert G.
  • Residential Real Estate Agent
  • Miami, FL
Replied Jun 30 2014, 14:42

Wow.  Excellent, Brian.  Really enjoyed following along, thanks for sharing.  And good luck with the sale!

User Stats

28
Posts
27
Votes
Mike Clark
  • Investor
  • San Antonio, TX
27
Votes |
28
Posts
Mike Clark
  • Investor
  • San Antonio, TX
Replied Jun 30 2014, 16:18

Finally the before and after pics ...trying to finish my rehab without constantly thinking about your rehab  was an exercise in patience.  Your before and after  pics are incredible...I got an idea why don't  you find another monstrosity and start a new thread

Congrats

User Stats

820
Posts
228
Votes
David Niles
Pro Member
  • Property Manager
  • DeLand FL
228
Votes |
820
Posts
David Niles
Pro Member
  • Property Manager
  • DeLand FL
Replied Jun 30 2014, 17:21

Holy crap Brian, spider webs look like those fake ones you buy for Halloween. lmao.

While I havent had that much debris like this before, I have had a cat pee house that would knock your nose off.  Lots of demo and Kilz oil FTW.  

Good luck, shes an ambitious one thats for sure. 

Maxim Realtors Logo

User Stats

33
Posts
12
Votes
Sonja Pope
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Mahwah, NJ
12
Votes |
33
Posts
Sonja Pope
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Mahwah, NJ
Replied Jun 30 2014, 20:27

What a flip! Congrats to @Brian Burke  on a job well done! So glad I discovered this thread after the "after" pics were posted. I would not have been able to handle the anticipation, LOL!

Looking forward to seeing your next success!

Account Closed
  • Investor
  • Central Valley, CA
3,724
Votes |
6,037
Posts
Account Closed
  • Investor
  • Central Valley, CA
Replied Jun 30 2014, 21:02
Originally posted by @Brian Burke:

Thanks for all the additional info.  The laminate looks really great.  I'm not familiar with good laminate and have never even considered it. I really like the color and texture.

I was wondering if the pavers on sand were more staging than landscaping, but wasn't sure.  Given the level of the patio door, a deck makes sense. But let the new owners build it!

The double door master bedroom entry is not something I've seen before in that style/age CA house.  IMO you did the right thing to work with the existing frame opening and replace the doors.  But it's so weirdly useless.  Like so much from the 80s. :)

Any more offers come in today?

User Stats

27
Posts
3
Votes
Cathy McCormick
Pro Member
  • Dunnellon, FL
3
Votes |
27
Posts
Cathy McCormick
Pro Member
  • Dunnellon, FL
Replied Jun 30 2014, 21:03

I just listened to the podcast, and I had to check out your pictures. They are unbelievable! I can't wait to see the after photos!

User Stats

319
Posts
153
Votes
Larmon Cummings Jr
  • Flipper/Rehabber
  • Chicago, IL
153
Votes |
319
Posts
Larmon Cummings Jr
  • Flipper/Rehabber
  • Chicago, IL
Replied Jun 30 2014, 21:58

That was interesting...look forward to the updates as you fix it up.

User Stats

2,207
Posts
6,589
Votes
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
6,589
Votes |
2,207
Posts
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
Replied Jun 30 2014, 22:11
Originally posted by @David Niles:

Holy crap Brian, spider webs look like those fake ones you buy for Halloween. lmao. 

That's hilarious, I said the same exact thing! 

User Stats

658
Posts
315
Votes
Brant Richardson
  • Investor
  • Santa Barbara, CA
315
Votes |
658
Posts
Brant Richardson
  • Investor
  • Santa Barbara, CA
Replied Jun 30 2014, 22:12

I would love to know how many bags of cat litter it took to fill the house.  They probably could have made the place beautiful for the cost of the cat litter.  Junior grew up so happy there, the whole house was a sand box.

Amazing job.  My wife laughs at the pictures of houses I am interested in and says "that's a tear down".  I'll have to show her your before and after photos.  Thanks for sharing it.

User Stats

2,207
Posts
6,589
Votes
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
6,589
Votes |
2,207
Posts
Brian Burke
Pro Member
#1 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Contributor
  • Investor
  • Santa Rosa, CA
Replied Jun 30 2014, 22:17
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

Any more offers come in today?

Yes, we've had two total so far.  I made a really onerous looking pictorial exhibit plus an extensive disclosure statement. Sending that out to buyers once they submit an offer. Both retracted their offer.  Not unexpected that this would happen, but I only want to sell to someone that fully understands what they are buying.  The right buyer will come along.